Sami Zayn’s Hard-Fought Reign: US Title Defenses, Open Challenges, and What’s Next

When wrestling fans think of the United States Championship in WWE, they often recall names like John Cena, AJ Styles, or even Rusev—superstars who’ve carried that title with intensity and prestige. As of September 2025, Sami Zayn has inserted himself into that lineage in a meaningful way. After winning the US Title, he’s defended it with guts and style, and now the next challenger has stepped forward.

The Turning Point: Sami’s Rise to US Champion

On August 29, 2025, in Lyon, France, Sami Zayn made a statement. Facing Solo Sikoa, who came in backed by his family-style “MFT” group, Zayn turned what looked like a tough night into a defining moment. Thanks to assistance from Jacob Fatu and Jimmy Uso, Zayn overcame Sikoa clean, capturing the US Title for the first time in his WWE career. TJR Wrestling

This was no fluke win. It marked a milestone in Sami’s journey. He has long been beloved for his underdog spirit, someone who works harder, outsmarts his opponents, and connects with the audience. Winning this title in Europe, far from the WWE’s usual American stronghold, added an extra emotional layer.

Defending the Honor (and the Belt)

Winning is one thing. Defending is where true champions are revealed. Sami’s first few weeks with the belt have been anything but easy.

John Cena & The Open Challenge Legacy

On September 5, during what turned out to be Cena’s final SmackDown appearance, Sami faced the legend in a match many saw as a passing-of-the-torch moment. Cena had famously executed the US Open Challenge several times in the past, defending the title against all comers. Zayn asked Cena if he could continue that tradition. Cena gave his blessing.

The match itself was solid, infused with nostalgia, technique, and respect, but ended in chaos when Brock Lesnar showed up and spoiled the finish. No definitive winner. But Sami’s posture and performance resonated. It wasn’t perfection, but it was a message: this title won’t just sit quietly around his waist.

Rey Fenix: Twenty-Minute Brawl

Fast forward to a SmackDown in Norfolk, VA, when Sami accepted an open challenge from Rey Fenix. These two tore into each other over nearly 20 minutes—hard strikes, high flying, near falls, and that WWE storytelling that builds tension. The crowd believed Fenix had a legitimate chance. But Sami delivered the finisher, the Helluva Kick, and escaped with the win. Some in the audience weren’t thrilled with perceived slow referee counts, but the result was clear: Sami still stands tall.

The Next Challenger: Carmelo Hayes

After the Fenix match, backstage drama built. Carmelo Hayes, a rising star many feel is already knocking on the door of main event status, approached Sami. He declared he wanted this shot at the US Title on September 19, 2025 SmackDown. Sami, for his part, welcomed the opportunity. A “fighting champion” knows value lies in defending against challengers who bring something new. Hayes is such a challenger.

What makes this especially compelling:

• Hayes is younger, high-energy, with a style that’s fast and slick.

• Fans often debate whether he’s ready for the biggest moments. A US Title match makes for a strong test.

• For Sami, this is another chance to build the title’s prestige, facing someone who could pull off an upset.

Historical Perspective: What the US Championship Has Meant

In order to truly understand what Sami Zayn is doing, it is beneficial to go backwards and see what the United States Championship has been within WWE history.

It was introduced in 1975 and revived a few times as the US Title (as a legacy of NWA/WWE). It has been a stepping stone throughout decades and a sign of steadiness, a contender who does not shine in a single game but in a series of matches.

Most superstars in the late 1990s and 2000s utilized US Title reigns to establish their own identity: Bret Hart, Eddie Guerrero, John Cena, and, more recently, such names as Seth Rollins and Kevin Owens.

The Open Challenge that John Cena was successful with in his subsequent US Title reign was popularized: any opponent, any style, any time. This made the champion higher not only to the challengers. Excitement is the possibility of surprise.

Sami Zayn is directly basing on such tradition. His flight up to this point is reminiscent of the spirit of defending anywhere, anytime, which makes legends special.

What’s On The Line, And What Sami Must Do

Heading into the match with Carmelo Hayes, Sami Zayn is carrying more than a championship belt. Here’s what’s at stake:

1. Credibility as a Champion
   If Sami is going to be viewed among the great US Champions, he needs to defend smart. The John Cena match may not have had a clean finish, but the Fenix match shows he can go long and hold up under pressure.

2. Elevating Carmelo Hayes
   A good champion helps the challenger look strong. If Hayes shines even in a loss, he’ll emerge as a legitimate threat in future storylines. Sami has already done this kind of work before.

3. Audience Investment
   With SmackDown in varying cities and countries, each title defense is an opportunity to engage fans who might not have seen Sami as champion yet. The Open Challenge format helps in that regard.

4. Diversifying Opponents
   Fenix was high flying; Hayes is more grounded, athletic, and aggressive in different ways. As a champion, facing different styles adds texture and keeps things fresh.

Predictions & Potential Outcomes

WWE tends to build toward moments where the champion looks strong, even if he loses. Some possible scenarios:

• Sami wins cleanly: This would solidify his place, sending a message that Hayes’ push is strong, but Sami is still king.

• Sami wins with controversy: Maybe interference, maybe a count-out, maybe referee shenanigans. That would protect Hayes (so he doesn’t lose credibility) and potentially lead to a longer feud.

• Hayes wins: A big moment. If Hayes can pull off the upset, WWE would have a fresh US champion heading into the fall. It’d signal a shift Sami would still be viewed highly, but Hayes would get a huge boost.

Commentary: Why Sami Zayn’s New Era Feels Different

Sami’s current run stands out for a few reasons:

• His international win (Lyon, France) gives global fans something to connect with, especially those outside US television markets.

• He’s embracing that “champion who fights open challenges, surprising opponents” role. It’s risky: every week brings potential loss or embarrassment. But that risk makes every match meaningful.

• He blends in-ring ability, character work, and storytelling more smoothly than many of his peers. Even when the matches end with controversy, he often manages to emerge with dignity or get goodwill from the crowd.

Historically, that was true of guys like Edge, Dolph Ziggler, or Kofi Kingston, who were super talented, often carrying the midcard with passion until the narrative pushes them upward. Sami is following that path.

Final Thoughts

Defending the US Championship against a variety of challengers—established stars like John Cena, unpredictable phenoms like Rey Fenix, and rising talents like Carmelo Hayes and Sami Zayn is not just holding a title. He’s trying to earn his place in the eyes of fans. Every match is a test: of endurance, of story, of audience belief.

September 19th’s match with Hayes may not just be another defense—it could define Sami’s reign, determining whether he becomes remembered alongside the greats of the US Title or whether this becomes just another good run in a long, distinguished career.

Stats & Highlights